Hefty fine over laybys

Chrisco Hampers Australia has been ordered to pay a $200,000 penalty for contravening the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).

In proceedings brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC),

the Federal Court found the company made false or misleading representation to consumers between January 2011 and December 2013 that consumers could not cancel their layby agreement after making their final payment.

The ACL provides that consumers have a right to cancel a layby agreement at any time prior to delivery of the goods, including after paying their final layby instalment.

The Court also found that Chrisco’s 2014 layby agreement contained an unfair contract term related to its HeadStart Plan, and allowed Chrisco to continue to take payments by direct debit after the consumer had fully paid for their layby order.

Consumers were required to opt out in order to avoid further payments being automatically deducted by Chrisco after their layby had been fully paid.

In concluding that this was an unfair contract term, Justice Edelman considered the agreement as a whole, the transparency of the term, and whether the term caused a significant imbalance in the rights and obligations between Chrisco and its customers arising from the agreement.

“We understand that making purchases by layby agreement is a convenient way for many Australians to shop, particularly for products such as Christmas hampers and presents” ACCC Chairman, Rod Sims, said.

“The Australian Consumer Law provides that layby agreements must be in writing and transparent. Consumers have termination rights at any time before the delivery of the goods, subject to a reasonable termination charge in some circumstances,” Mr Sims said.

“The importance of the penalty imposed by the Court against Chrisco is that it sends a strong message to businesses using layby as a method of sale that they must meet all of their ACL obligations, and do not mislead consumers about their rights.”

Further information on layby agreements is available for consumers and businesses on the ACCC’s website.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

FURTHER READING

Retail Voice CEO Message: 20 September 2023

Last week, the ARA convened our inaugural Retail Crime Symposium, bringing together representatives from the nation’s top major retailers face-to-face to address this pressing issue. Distinguished speakers at the symposium

The importance of R U OK? Day

September 14 is R U OK? Day in Australia, where millions of people around Australia will take the time to check in with family, friends and peers to ask if

Retail Voice CEO Message: 6 September 2023

On Monday, the Federal Government tabled Tranche 3 of its controversial workplace relations reforms, the Closing the Loopholes Bill. The ARA released a media statement opposing the Bill, which seeks

How sonic branding can reassure your shoppers

When it comes to giving peace of mind to shoppers and building trust at the checkout, the value of familiarity and assurance cannot be overstated.   In fact, according to Mastercard